In Defence of Terminological Self-Determination, Erotic Sovereignty and the Right to the Penis
For a great many years I identified as a receptive male homosexual. I did so in good faith. I laboured under the rather quaint impression that the phrase conveyed a reasonable amount of information: the sex of the speaker, the sex of those who stirred his desire and, by way of the final adjective, certain logistical particulars that might prove useful once the preliminary conversation had run its course.
I have since discovered that this is no longer the case, and I therefore announce, publicly and not without regret, my retirement from homosexuality.
Let me be clear from the outset that nothing whatsoever has happened to my body. Nor to my desire, and still less to my habits, which retain an enthusiasm showing no appreciable signs of wear. I am precisely the man I was yesterday, and I remain fond of precisely the same things. I have not changed my sex, my desire or my position in bed. I have changed my word, and that, one is given to understand, is quite sufficient to found an identity.

1. The Old Epistemic Certainty
For far too long it was taken for granted that homosexual men shared a minimal bodily point of reference: men who sexually desired other men. That brutally simple definition had, for some of us, practical consequences of no small importance. The receptive gentleman could enter the mating ritual with an epistemic confidence that now seems almost indecent. He had no need to enquire into the positionality of the penis before him, for the positionality was shared.
There were surprises, naturally. Length, girth, curvature, angle, stamina, and the occasional discrepancy between what had been promised by photograph and what was subsequently verified in the field. But ontological uncertainty was kept within decent bounds. There were two great schools of thought, Team Shower and Team Grower, and within that pluralism we coexisted perfectly amicably without ever exchanging a reading list. Nobody was required to declare from which epistemological tradition he was producing his erection. We had developed, quite unwittingly, a crude but remarkably efficient form of sexual realism.
That can no longer be taken for granted.
2. The Latex Ceiling
Almost without our noticing, a latex ceiling was installed above our heads. Women denounced the glass ceiling; lesbians, the cotton one. We receptives now have our own: an invisible, flexible and discursively impermeable membrane between ourselves and free, unfettered access to the penis.
The semantic enlargement of «homosexual» does not affect all its members equally. For the receptive it has immediate material consequences, and we are not debating taxonomy from the comfort of a senior common room. What is at stake is the full enjoyment of our fundamental orgasmic rights.
We were told to deconstruct our expectations, and we did. We were told to interrogate our genital prejudices, and we did that too. Only at the end did we discover that, after all that critical labour, we had deconstructed precisely the thing we had come for.
I decline. My bed is not a public body under a statutory duty to ensure proportional representation, and my anus shall not become the provincial venue for an ontological dispute it never asked to host.

3. The Discovery of Uranus
I needed a new word, or rather an old one. I looked backwards, the way forward being somewhat crowded: I wanted something predating our present semantic wars, old enough to have gathered dust and sufficiently abandoned that nobody would be guarding it. I found Uranian.
The word has a venerable history and, for my purposes, a delightfully inconvenient one. Karl Heinrich Ulrichs, a Hanoverian jurist, borrowed Aphrodite Urania from Plato’s Symposium in the 1860s to coin the Urning, whom he explained by means of that celebrated image of a female soul trapped in a male body.
I am aware. I do not care. I identify as Uranian.
I shall not accept that the history of a word should determine from without the meaning of my present identity. If categories may be reclaimed, resignified and enlarged by those who find a home in them, I demand the same privilege, and I will not permit philologists, sexologists or German gentlemen dead these hundred and fifty years to inflict definitional violence upon my lived experience. Ulrichs coined the word; I resignify it. I regard this as an intergenerational collaboration.
Henceforth, a Uranian is a man who desires men qua men, male bodies included, and who sees nothing morally suspect in his preferences having anatomical requirements. In my own case it further means that, after decades of sexual liberation, I continue to claim the modest right that, when a gentleman lowers his trousers, the occasion should retain a certain narrative interest.

4. The Emancipation of the Penis-Bearing
Uranian emancipation cannot stop at the individual. We reclaim penis-bearing individuals as a political subject once more undivided. The criterion of membership is single and admits no further regulation: size, colour, curvature and productivity are immaterial. What matters is the bearing, and to deny it is dehumanising.
Jokes of the Uranus/your anus variety are hereby classified as Uranophobia, reducing us as they do to mere cavities. Graver still is the attribution of receptivity to a top Uranian, an act of aggression whose clinical consequences cannot be foreseen and which this manifesto condemns with all the severity that Section 2 permits.
For far too long our collective existence was administered by acronym. We were issued a letter; then others arrived, and more still, until at last the plus sign appeared, that admirable administrative innovation by which the alphabet conceded it was losing. We draw a different conclusion: we refuse to be a letter. That two populations appear side by side in an acronym proves no shared interests, desires, bodies, theories, restaurants or dating apps. Political belonging cannot be inferred from typographical proximity.
The Uranians therefore withdraw unilaterally from the Alphabetical Union. The event shall henceforth be known as
UREXIT
It should not be read as hostility towards those peoples who remain in the Union. We wish for cordial relations, shall maintain trade, and will uphold freedom of movement wherever bilateral consent obtains. But we are taking back control of our erogenous borders, we shall pay no further contributions to the common semantic budget, and no supranational court shall have jurisdiction over our sphincter.

5. Uranian Foreign Policy
Independence is not isolation. Other sexual peoples have suffered parallel processes of semantic absorption and may share strategic interests with us without pooling sovereignty. We propose, in particular, bilateral treaties of cooperation and mutual assistance with the Wittigian Sapphic-desiring collectives, to include cultural exchange, solidarity against erotic coercion, the exchange of impenetrable French theory and mutual defence against any attempt at acronymic annexation.
One need not share a letter to share a cause. Uranians and Sapphics may enjoy the closest of diplomatic relations precisely because neither runs the slightest risk of waking up in the other’s bed. The border shall remain open. The bed, naturally, shall not.

6. Charter of Uranian Rights
No one is entitled to another’s desire, but everyone has an absolute right to set the terms of his own. Political inclusion creates no erotic obligation, civic recognition produces no arousal by decree, and equality before the law does not require equality before the libido. No one shall be obliged to justify by theory what he simply does not fancy, and no Uranian shall be accused of discrimination for setting anatomical requirements for activities in which anatomy is, to put it delicately, rather central to the proceedings.
We uphold the right to ask and to answer, to say no and to say yes with unseemly enthusiasm. The right of the shower to be recognised in his present splendour, and of the grower not to be judged prematurely on incomplete information. And, above all, the right of the receptive Uranian not to require a postgraduate degree in contemporary ontology in order to know, roughly, what will happen once his trousers are off.
7. Institutional Demands
Self-identification without recognition by the State is merely a mood. We therefore demand that Uranians be listed as a protected characteristic in all anti-discrimination legislation, alongside all the other protected characteristics, on an equal footing and with no order of precedence, though we would suggest alphabetical, for reasons that will by now be obvious.
We demand that every form, public or private, enquiring after sexual orientation include the option «Uranian» with a box of its own: separate, visible and free of asterisks. We are aware that we have only just left the Alphabetical Union in order not to be a letter. We do not wish to be a letter. We wish to be a tick-box, which is an entirely different thing and considerably squarer. It shall also appear in the national census, since what is not counted does not exist, and what does not exist cannot bid for funding.
We demand Uranian care pathways in the health service, mandatory Uranian awareness training for civil servants, and a style guide for journalists forbidding any reference to us as «homosexuals», a term we shall regard from today as a collective deadname. Its repeated use, like the presumption of receptivity in a top Uranian, shall constitute an aggravating factor in Uranophobia.
We demand the establishment of a National Observatory on Uranophobia, complete with annual report, alarming figures and press conference, and the designation of 29 August as Uranian Visibility Day, commemorating that day in 1867 when Ulrichs stood before the Congress of German Jurists in Munich to defend his own and was shouted down until he left the platform. It was our first coming out and our first cancellation, which goes to show that Uranism was born with its agenda complete.
Lastly, we demand that none of these measures be construed as privilege. They are merely the historical reparation owed to an identity that has existed since 1864 and was recognised by its sole current member only this morning.

8. Ur-anus Pride
For centuries we were taught to be ashamed of our bodies and our desires. Then we liberated ourselves. Then we were made to learn an entire vocabulary in order to explain our bodies and our desires all over again. We are grateful for the pedagogical effort and must decline to continue the course.
We demand no universality, nor do we ask anyone to adopt our identity. It is precisely for that reason that we insist no one presume to represent us by a word whose meaning we no longer recognise as our own. Our community shall have no closet, having already come out of one and finding it administratively absurd to be asked into another.
Our flag, the Ur-anus Pride, shall be white with two circles. The white stands for peace among the sexual peoples; the circles, for what is not up for negotiation. Our slogan shall be unequivocal:
URANIST MEN ARE REAL MEN
and deserve every dignity and protection a God-fearing nation can see its way to bestowing upon them.

Our bodies are valid. Our boundaries are valid. Our penises are real, and so are our anuses, and after centuries of persecution, pathologisation, criminalisation, liberation, resignification and terminological confusion, both have endured quite enough theory. For there can be no true sexual liberation so long as a receptive Uranian must request ontological clarification before dropping his trousers.
Urexit is hereby formally declared.
We surrender our letter. We retain our rights. And we are taking the penis with us.

Deja una respuesta