EN  ·  ES

Donald Trump has just discovered one of those phrases the United States exported to the world along with Coca-Cola, aircraft carriers and morbid obesity: actions have consequences.

For years it served to explain to ordinary citizens that freedom does not mean immunity from the consequences of their actions. You can say what you like, do what you like within the law and defend whatever ideas you like. Then deal with the response. It turns out this also works for presidents.

The White House decided that CNN, MS NOW and Politico should not be part of the usual presidential press coverage arrangement. CNN had its turn in the pool. It was not allowed in. So far, Trump being Trump: the man has never encountered an institutional boundary he did not want to touch just to see whether it was live.

What happened next was more interesting. ABC, CBS, NBC and Fox News could have accepted the substitution. Technically, it was simple. One outlet was out, another stepped in, the cameras kept rolling and everybody went home. They said no. Five competitors discovered that taking the empty chair of an adversary might prove rather more expensive than defending the chair itself.

Because chairs rotate.

Trump governs today. Tomorrow someone else will. Then someone else after that. This is one of democracy’s delightfully inconvenient features: power changes arses. If today you accept that a president may decide which outlet deserves to be present according to how much he likes its coverage, you have just written the instruction manual for the next president free of charge. And the next one may hate you.

Fox News does not need to love CNN to understand that. It only needs to know how to count to four years.

That is the difference between defending someone and defending a rule. A rule we regard as sacred only when it benefits our side is not a rule; it is merchandise. A good part of contemporary politics consists precisely in discovering universal principles when our team loses the ball and forgetting them the moment we get it back.

This time there was not even any need for constitutional epic. Montesquieu did not descend from the heavens wrapped in the First Amendment. Nor did five television executives have to embrace one another while singing We Shall Overcome. Something far less romantic, and probably more durable, was enough: institutional self-interest. Networks have reasons not to grant the executive a tool that can reward the friendly journalist and punish the inconvenient one, because political tools have the unpleasant habit of outliving their inventors.

The progressive who wants a particular power for the state today should imagine it administered tomorrow by a conservative. The conservative who celebrates Trump excluding CNN should imagine exactly the same power in the hands of the next Democratic president. If, after that small mental exercise, the instrument suddenly looks less wonderful, congratulations: you have just discovered liberalism. You will survive.

And this shows something that disappears when democracy is reduced to constitutions, elections and courts. Power has limits that are not always written into law. Trump remains president and retains the constitutional powers of his office. Nobody stormed the Capitol, no general appeared on television and no tanks rolled down Pennsylvania Avenue. Something much more ordinary happened: other institutional actors decided they would not cooperate with a practice they regarded as dangerous to their own independence.

They said no.

That monosyllable is part of democracy too.

We have an almost pornographic fascination with presidents, parliaments and courts. We stare upwards so much that we end up imagining all power lives inside buildings with columns. But a democracy is also made of associations, universities, companies, trade unions, journalists, judges, civil servants and citizens capable of withdrawing cooperation, imposing costs and defending spaces of their own. The state may possess formidable instruments; that does not mean it can manufacture legitimacy or cooperation on demand.

The irony is particularly delicious with Trump. Much of his political persona was built around a very American sensibility: stop whining, take the consequences, nobody owes you anything. Perfect. Television does not owe you anything either.

If you expel one member of the pool, the others can refuse to replace it. If you restrict certain outlets’ access, those outlets can take you to court. If you treat independent coverage as a privilege dependent on presidential favour, those whose work depends on that independence may conclude that accepting the precedent would cost them too much. None of this requires turning them into heroes of the resistance.

CNN, Fox, NBC, ABC and CBS are enormous media conglomerates with commercial interests, editorial lines, shareholders, competition and power of their own. They are not the Sisters of Charity with 4K cameras. They can defend a principle, their access, their business and their institutional position all at once. Demanding moral purity before recognising an institutional defence would mean asking democracy to function only through saints, a rather poor political design given the historical scarcity of the product.

In fact, a robust institution often appears precisely when principles and interests manage to walk in the same direction for a while. We do not need Fox to feel tenderness for CNN. It is enough for Fox to understand that a presidential prerogative created against CNN can survive perfectly well until a president comes along who decides to use it against Fox.

And there appears precedent, that legal and political creature every ruler imagines he is manufacturing exclusively for personal use. He never is.

Every expansion of power comes with a question that should be printed on the door of every government office: would I still want this power if my opponent were exercising it? It is a much more useful test than asking whether we like what the current government is doing. It forces us to think about rules without knowing in advance who will hold the keys tomorrow.

That is why this episode matters beyond Trump and far beyond CNN. It shows a democratic mechanism less spectacular than a Supreme Court ruling but just as necessary: power tests a boundary, meets resistance and discovers a cost. It then has to decide whether to insist, retreat, negotiate or look for another route. Nothing guarantees that the boundary will hold forever, but neither was it guaranteed that anyone would defend it.

This time, someone did.

Perhaps Trump expected excluding certain outlets to demonstrate who was in charge. It ended up demonstrating something much more interesting: in a democracy, being in charge never means being in charge alone. Others retain resources, interests, rights and the capacity to respond. Even those who applauded you yesterday may need tomorrow the rule you are eroding today.

For decades, the United States has repeated to the world that freedom does not erase consequences.

This week it had the opportunity to remind its president.

Actions have consequences, Mr. President.

Welcome to democracy.