EN · ES
WhatsApp, the imaginary right to availability, and why, if you think I’m dead, you should call.

The Nokia 1100 was not morally superior technology. It was a limited piece of shit with Snake. Precisely because of that, it had one accidental virtue: it knew very little about you and even less about the other person.
You sent an SMS and then went back to being another miserable bean floating in the broth of ignorance or, depending on the day, ignominy. You did not know whether it had arrived, whether it had been read, whether the other person was working, sleeping, fucking, out of credit or staring at the ceiling with the same metaphysical intensity with which people now stare at two blue ticks.
Silence was not an event. It was what happened between one message and the next.
There was no “online”, “last seen”, “typing…” or any of the emotional telemetry that turned the telephone into a mixture of lie detector, sentimental ECG and parliamentary inquiry. Someone could take four hours to reply and you had relatively few tools with which to manufacture a novel. They’re out of credit. They’ll see it later. They’ll call if it matters. The end. Uncertainty still fitted inside the device.
WhatsApp did not invent anxiety. Anxiety had already been invented perfectly well and was running at full capacity long before Zuckerberg realised he could give it green indicators. What WhatsApp did was give it instrumentation.
Now we know the message left. We know it arrived. We can know it was read. We can know the other person was online. That they came online again. That they changed their profile picture. That they posted a status. That they liked some piece of idiocy on Instagram and yet still have not replied to our “hi”.
That changes things considerably. Once, somebody not replying did not mean very much. Now you can watch them online, watch them come and go, repost a cat video or forward Temu invitations while still not answering you; inevitably you begin to think the silence is specifically for you, because apparently you are the lint in the navel of my universe.
That is where the soap opera begins. They’re angry. They’re ignoring me. Something is off. Something happened. There was an accident. They died. In eight minutes we have gone from two blue ticks to an autopsy.
Our deep psychology did not need to change. The interface did. We gave millions of people a tiny control panel displaying somebody else’s presence and then acted surprised when they began reading every light as if Delphi had outsourced the oracle to Meta.
The phone made it possible to reach one another almost all the time and, without signing anything, we decided that meant being available almost all the time.
I can have my phone in my pocket and still be unavailable. I can have read your message and decide to answer three hours later. I can even read it, think “I’ll deal with that later” and carry on with my life without a full-blown soap opera being born between us.
But this is roughly the implicit contract we have built around the phone: relatives, friends, colleagues, hookups and assorted forms of Shag-N-Go acquire, merely by pressing “send”, a small claim on your time. Nobody signed anything. Yet apparently existing within a few metres of a smartphone now amounts to being permanently on call.
And then come the liturgical phrases.
“I sent you a thousand messages.”
“I saw you were online.”
“I thought something had happened to you.”
I adore the last one. It presents itself as concern, but very often it describes something else.
If you genuinely thought something had happened to me, let us treat the hypothesis with a minimum of epistemological respect. If your working theory is that I may be unconscious, injured or dead next to the water heater, there is a button that has been available for decades. It looks like a telephone. Call me.
A phone call has one rather unpleasant property: it forces you to reveal how much you really believed in the emergency. If you sent twelve messages, three stickers, four question marks and a “helloooo????” but never called, perhaps you were not checking whether I was alive. Perhaps you were checking whether I was obedient.
And there the leash appears.
So my protocol is fairly clean: if you think I am dead, call me. If you do not call, do not later stage a prestige drama about how terribly worried you were. If you sent twelve messages and never rang once, you were clearly not arranging for the body to be collected. You wanted an answer and were one message away from going full telenovela villain.
And yes, I considered explaining all this individually to each of the 878 WhatsApp messages currently waiting for me. Then I pictured the result and realised I would end up performing a one-man family farce.
More or less everyone would receive the same answer: “First, I said it because I have a tongue; second, I said it because we live in an independent, sovereign country, without censorship, with freedom of expression and whatever else; and third, because I felt like it.”
At a certain point not every boundary needs to be grounded in Kant, the Constitution and three meta-analyses. Sometimes you do not answer because you do not want to answer. Full stop.
And that connects to something larger than WhatsApp. The fact that you can find me almost all the time does not mean I have to be there for you almost all the time. Technology made it technically possible to locate me nearly always; we turned that possibility into an imaginary right to interrupt me.
That is the problem. Not “screens”. Not “dopamine”. Not “modern society is disconnecting us from our inner selves”, a sentence that should be punishable by one week with a Nokia and no charger.
I do not want to go back to 2003. I do not want to abandon screens. If I switch off my phone, I will probably sit down at my computer and write something equally unnecessary about Žižek, Lacan, AI or some national catastrophe of epistemology. I am not denouncing silicon. I am denouncing a politics of access.
There are hours when my attention is occupied. Properly occupied. Not corporate “I’ve got a few things on” occupied. I am trying to build an idea that does not quite exist yet. There is an intuition, an objection, a sentence that half works, another one that sounds as though ChatGPT wrote it wearing a tie, and a relation to another idea that still refuses to close.
For a few minutes all of that stays suspended together.
Then the phone vibrates.
“Hi.”
And the whole thing goes to shit.
The great accounting fraud of interruptions consists in measuring how long the notification itself lasted. “It was one second.” No. Looking at the phone took one second. Returning to the previous mental state can take ten minutes, twenty, or simply never happen.
The cost is not the second you spent looking. It is having to return to the document and remember exactly where the fuck you were.
That is why you return to the document feeling as though someone entered the room and moved every piece of furniture five centimetres. Everything is there. Nothing is exactly where it was.
And that is why the irritation can look wildly disproportionate. A “hi” triggers an emotional response that, from the outside, seems better suited to a military invasion, a tax audit or a dick caught in a zip.
From the outside, it looks as though you went feral over “hi”. You know that “hi” lasted one second and that you then spent ten minutes digging through the rubble for the idea you had before it arrived.
And nine times out of ten the interruption did not even have a time-sensitive justification. There was no fire. Nobody had died. There was no urgent decision. There was a meme. A question that could wait. A comment whose shelf life comfortably exceeded the next fifteen minutes. Or simply someone who pressed send and, from that instant, began behaving as though the universe had delegated to you an obligation to reply.
Someone interrupts your concentration without invitation, unilaterally sets the deadline for your reply and then, if you do not answer, somehow you are the rude bastard. I think that is what the kids call gaslighting, or however the hell they spell it.
It is the only home invasion in which the owner ends up apologising for not opening the door quickly enough.
At least Moria Casán had the decency to say, “if you want to cry, cry”. We invented a worse version:
“If you want to be alone, perfectly fine. Just tell me, explain why, tell me how long it will last and answer me when I message you.”
An extraordinarily well-administered freedom.
Since I stopped treating every silence as something that needed an explanation, I have been considerably more peaceful.
It means nothing.
I may be writing, sleeping, with a hookup (or with another hookup, if you happen to be the hookup) or staring at a wall. Maybe I saw the message and plan to answer later. Or maybe, and this is a major journalistic scoop… at that particular moment I simply do not feel like talking to you.
That too should be legally admissible.
If you need to turn my silence into a medical emergency, call me. If you do not call, spare me the subsequent epic of care.
And if you genuinely thought I was dead but calling seemed too intrusive, I deeply appreciate the delicacy. I hope you maintain it at the funeral.
Meanwhile, I am still trying to condense that Žižek sentence that would not quite close.
Your “hi???” can wait.
Deja una respuesta